How to Write Linguistics Puzzle Solutions That Show Your Reasoning

Knowing how to write linguistics puzzle solutions means making the link between the examples and your answer visible. In the Qualification Round, you must provide a written analysis and explanation of your reasoning for every problem. A correct answer alone does not meet that requirement: it tells the reader what you got, but not what pattern you found or how you used it. Your rough notes may already contain that reasoning. The job of your final write-up is to put it where someone else can follow it.
How to write linguistics puzzle solutions from rough notes
Rough notes are for you. A question mark can mark a guess, a circle can flag a repeated letter, and an arrow can stand for a step you understand without writing it out. Your reader does not share those shortcuts. Before you copy anything into your solution, sort the useful parts of your notes into three groups:
- Rule: State what changes, what stays the same, and when the pattern applies.
- Evidence: Point to examples from the problem and explain what their comparison shows.
- Application: Show what the rule does to the item you were asked to solve.
This is a way to organize your explanation, not a required format. A short paragraph may do all three jobs. For a problem with several patterns, a table may make the evidence easier to read. Either way, write out the connection. If your notes say same ending!, tell the reader which forms share the ending and what their translations have in common.
Build a written solution from one set of notes
Suppose an invented puzzle gives you the forms below and asks for the phrase meaning my cups. The row labels let you refer back to specific examples without copying the whole table into your answer.
| Row | Form | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| A | palo | cup |
| B | paloti | cups |
| C | mipalo | my cup |
| D | senu | basket |
| E | senuti | baskets |
| F | misenu | my basket |
| G | misenuti | my baskets |
Your scratch work might read ti plural? B E; mi = my C F; G both; mipaloti. That is enough to remind you what you noticed. In the write-up, replace the question mark with a rule supported by the data, and replace G both with an explanation of why that row matters:
In these examples,
tigoes after the noun to mark more than one, andmigoes before the noun to mean “my.” Comparing A with B and D with E shows that addingtichanges “cup” to “cups” and “basket” to “baskets.” Comparing A with C and D with F shows that addingmichanges whose object it is without changing the number. Row G shows that the two markers can appear together, withmifirst andtilast. For “my cups,” start withpalo, putmibefore it andtiafter it, and writemipaloti.
The final form is the same as in the notes. What changes is that each step can now be checked. Row G does a job the other rows do not: it shows the order of the two markers when both appear in a single form.
Choose evidence that separates two explanations
Evidence is strongest when the examples you compare differ in the feature you are trying to explain. If you compare palo (“cup”) directly with mipaloti (“my cups”), two things change in the meaning at once: ownership and number. That comparison alone would not tell you whether mi means “my” or marks more than one. Compare palo with mipalo instead. Both refer to one cup, so the difference points to “my.”
A second comparison can do more than repeat the first. The basket forms show that mi is not just part of a special word for “my cup.” You do not need to list every row if several rows make the same point, but you should include examples that establish different parts of your rule. For instance, if one row shows that two markers can appear together, do not leave it out just because you have already explained each marker on its own.
Keep your claim as narrow as your evidence. “In these examples” is more accurate than “This language always does this” when all you have is the puzzle data. If a row seems to contradict your rule, check whether you left out a condition. Then write down that condition and cite the example that supports it.
Check the explanation before you submit
Read your write-up as if the scratch paper were gone. Check that each rule names the actual feature involved, such as a marker's position or a change in word order. When you cite a row, say what it demonstrates. If a question asks for several forms, make each answer easy to find and show which rule produces it. You can state a shared rule once rather than repeating it for every form.
The Qualification Round instructions require a written analysis and explanation for all problems. A phrase like “I used the same pattern” does not explain how an answer follows unless you identify the pattern and show how it applies. The requirement is to show your reasoning, not to report every guess you crossed out.
For a practice run, pick an item from the training and practice problems and write your explanation below your notes. Cover the final answer and try to reconstruct it using only your explanation and the problem data. If you still have to guess where a marker goes or which word comes first, add that missing step.
Frequently asked questions
Is a correct answer enough in the Qualification Round?
No. You must also provide a written analysis and explanation of your reasoning for every problem.
Do I need to include all my rough work?
No. Include the comparisons and steps that support your answer, not every guess you tried.
Can I use a table to show my reasoning?
Yes. Make clear what the examples in the table show and how they support the rule you apply.


