What Is Conversational Implicature? A Closer Look at Some

By Julia Berens · · 5 min read

An overhead view of a busy indoor hall with rows of counters and indistinct figures, in warm gold, brown, and gray tones.

Someone at a school assembly asks, “Are there any seats left?” A friend replies, “Some of the seats are taken.” You might start looking for an empty chair. But if your friend adds, “In fact, all of them,” you have to stop looking, even though the first sentence wasn't false. That small change gets at the question “What is conversational implicature?” It's meaning a speaker conveys without saying it outright, and a listener works it out from the words, the situation, and what would make sense as a reply.

What is conversational implicature in the seat example?

Focus on one part of your first reaction: you took some to mean some but not all. The reply explicitly tells you that seats are taken. It doesn't explicitly tell you that any are left. If every seat is taken, then it's still true that at least one is taken. So where did the idea that there were seats left come from?

Imagine that your friend has a clear view of the whole room and knows which seats are available. If none are left, “All of the seats are taken” answers your question more directly than “Some of the seats are taken.” Since your friend chose the less informative reply, you have a reason to think the stronger one wouldn't be true. On that reading, not all is the implicature.

That reasoning depends on what your friend could reasonably know. Suppose your friend can see only the front row and says, “Some of the seats are taken. I can't see the back rows from here.” Now you have less reason to think any seats are left. Your friend may have stopped at some because that's all they could confirm, not because they knew all was false. The wording hasn't changed, but your evidence about the speaker has.

Adding “in fact, all of them”

Read the full reply as if the speaker pauses and takes another look:

“Some of the seats are taken. In fact, all of them.”

The second sentence takes back the suggestion that there are seats left. It doesn't take back the claim that seats are taken. Linguists call this cancellation: the speaker adds information that blocks or removes an implicature without contradicting what was literally said. The full reply may sound like a strange way to give a simple answer. That awkwardness makes sense if the first sentence leads you to expect a different ending.

Now compare “Some of the seats are taken, but not all of them. In fact, all of them are taken.” This time, the speaker has said not all out loud. If both statements refer to the same seats at the same time, they cannot both be true. You could make sense of the exchange as a correction, but not as two compatible claims. In the first version, the speaker can keep the original claim and drop only the inference. In the second, the speaker has to give up something they actually said.

Why a weaker word can suggest more

The seat example is a scalar implicature. The term refers to alternatives ordered by how much they tell you. Here, all makes a stronger claim than some: whenever all the seats are taken, some are taken, but the reverse doesn't follow. Using the weaker word can suggest that the speaker isn't in a position to use the stronger one. When the listener expects the speaker to know the full situation, that can lead to the more specific inference that the stronger claim is false.

The question itself also matters. Suppose an organizer asks, “Has anyone started taking seats yet?” The reply “Some of the seats are taken” gives the organizer enough information to answer that question with a yes. The exact share of seats taken may be beside the point. Compare that with “Are there any seats left?” Now the difference between some and all determines whether you should keep looking. The same answer gives you a stronger reason to pay attention to the word the speaker didn't use.

The philosopher H. P. Grice explained conversational implicature by looking at what people expect from each other in conversation. One expectation is that a reply will be as informative as the exchange calls for. That doesn't mean people must say everything they know. A useful answer to “Has anyone started taking seats yet?” doesn't need a row-by-row count. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on implicature explains Grice's account and how it connects what speakers say with what they convey.

A reply can imply a plan

Not every conversational implicature comes from choosing a weaker word. Suppose you ask, “Can you help me hang these posters after school?” Your classmate replies, “I have soccer practice right after class.” The sentence says something about a schedule. It doesn't literally say no. But because you asked about a particular time, you can connect the timing of practice with the timing of your request and infer that your classmate probably can't help then.

Now give the answer a second sentence: “I have soccer practice right after class, but I can help you hang the posters before I go.” The schedule hasn't changed. What changes is your interpretation of why the speaker mentioned it. The reply no longer sounds like a refusal. It sounds like an offer with a time limit. Unlike the seat example, there's no pair like some and all to compare. The inference comes from figuring out how the reply relates to the request.

Try changing just the question

Write “I finished the introduction” on a piece of paper. First, put it after “What did you finish this afternoon?” Then put it after “Is your whole essay ready to submit?” In which exchange does it sound more like an admission that there's work left? The second question makes completion of the whole essay relevant. Naming only one part in response can suggest that the speaker can't yet say the whole essay is ready.

For a check, add “In fact, the whole essay is ready” to both versions. Ask a partner to mark what the first sentence actually claims and underline what they initially inferred. If you want to connect that exercise to linguistics problems, see how the competition rounds work and browse the ILC learning resources.

Frequently asked questions

Does “some” always mean “not all”?

No. “Some” often suggests “not all,” but the context can weaken or remove that suggestion. You can say “Some of the seats are taken. In fact, all of them” without contradicting yourself.

Is every inference a conversational implicature?

No. A conversational implicature is something a speaker conveys indirectly. You might infer that a friend is tired from the sound of their voice even if they aren't trying to communicate that.

What does it mean to cancel an implicature?

It means making clear that an indirect suggestion shouldn't be taken as part of the message. The original literal claim can still stand.